The following is a rubric for how this project will be graded. Type an analysis following the class model for analyzing a poem. Ap english literature and composition scoring rubrics effective fall 2019 september 2019. Comments, reflections, analysis and connections are made regularly throughout the journal, but are often broad and concrete. Addresses some important details, some analysis supported by quotations. Students are expected to consider the role of syntax, diction, the effect of voice, tone, and imagery in a work of literary merit. Paper demonstrates understanding of the assignment and is an analysis of the assigned short stories andor poems paper considers both assigned purpose analysis and audience reader familiar with short story analysis uses aspects of the story to support essays argument without becoming a plot summary. The packet not only contains the general rubric that. This rubric is based on the bc performance standards and is intended as criteria for grade 12 students as they write poems. Essay displays insightful understanding and analysis of the book. Use this literary analysis rubric to help clarify expectations for students not only on the structure of their essay, but also on the depth and complexity of their thinking and ideas. Poetry rubric writing craft evidence 1 limited no 2 basic sort of 3 satisfactory yes 4 accomplished yes, but its awesome. The analysis examines implications, complexities and tensions, andor underlying values and assumptions.
Students are scored on accuracy as well as their overall presentation skills. Details of construction form, rhetoric, syntax, vocabulary addresses all important details. Student understands some parts of the poem and accurately answers some question related to. Ideally, you should add the title of the essay at the top of the page. Though not without flaws, these papers will offer a convincing interpretation of the poem, as well as consistent. You must also turn in the annotated poem along with your typed up analysis paragraph.
The poem does not enable the reader to see, hear, feel, or think about the subject. Choose two poems from the english curriculum document that we. Students should be assigned an accuracy score for each recitation. Rubric for critical analysis essay caroline county public. In addition, this rubric addresses the products of analysis and inquiry, not the processes. The analysis will be graded using the rubric below. It asks students to read an article, write an evidencebased argument in. Comparative poetry analysis argumen tative writing rubric a. Poetry use this rubric when you are having your students write their own poetry. The writing process effort student devoted a lot of time and effort to the writing process and worked hard to make the poem a good read. There is no useor consistently confusing or inappropriate use of sensory details. Poetry anthology rubric ideascontent organization conventions excellent 4 all required elements are included effectiveclosed form poems reflect insight into the subtleties of respective style and structure poem selections and justifications show critical awareness as well as appreciation the anthology is sharp. Poetry analysis choose one of the musical poems offered. The rubric utilizes a simple symbol system to get input from both student and teacher.
Addresses some important details but vaguely andor doesnt quote to support points. Rubric format 5 follows class model for analyzing a poem exactly. The structure of a poetry analysis essay is pretty straightforward, seeing as it merely serves as a recommendation that you should consider when creating the first rough outline. Poem recitations can be difficult to grade, however this rubric makes it easy. Poetry explication rubric easy peasy allinone high school. Advanced focus 30 pts essay continuously addresses both selected poems with a highly focused and convincing response readingresearch 10 pts demonstrates accurate and effective use of both selected poems to develop argument and. Expectations are clearly defined, which makes it easier for the grader and the presenter. Student seems to understand most of the poem and accurately answers most questions related to the poem. Ideas are present, engaging, logical, and support development of ideas the ideas in the poem provide a unique. Poetry organization and overall impact elements of poetry grammar, usage, mechanics, and spelling the form of the poem is not appropriate to the subject.
Poem analysis rubric level 1 level 2 level 3 understanding of task demonstrates little or no understanding of the task. Ks 500level classes outstanding a range above average b range competent c range insufficient d to f range writers approach the analysis presents fresh and defensible insights into the work being analyzed. Development of ideas and support for claims deepen. Students use of word usage students use of students use of. Poem analysis rubric category 4 3 2 1 comprehension student clearly understands the poem and accurately answers questions related to the story. Did not use evidence from the text to back up interpretation. The writers ethos is one of confidence and competence.
Poetry essays earning a score in this range respond effectively and insightfully, addressing all of the critical attributes completely and demonstrating clear understanding of the poem, including complexities of attitude or tone. In other words, after reading the poem, every time i see the subject, i think and recall the emotional tone of the poem. Please turn in this rubric with your final copies of your poetry and your rough drafts with editing comments. Poetry pomerantz poetry portfolio rubric dimension exemplary satisfactory unsatisfactory quality of. Key words differentiating levels are bolded, to help students key in on elements that help them advance their perfo. Rubric title college english 102 literary analysis rubric. Thesis presents a strong assertion or claim, is tightly focused. You will be creating a scrapbook of poems to give to your mother or grandma for mothers day this year. The directed selfplacement for writing for firstyear students dsp gives incoming students a chance to learn about the types of academic writing most often assigned and valued at the university of michigan. Possibly the scientific problem has been formulated by the student. Beginning 1 developing 2 accomplished 3 exemplary 4 score form uses an inappropriate poetic form. Explore free downloadable rubrics for use with turnitin feedback studio.
An interesting subject is defined and supported throughout the poem. Comparative poetry analysis argumentative writing rubric. Poetry rubric message points description 1520 excellent message is compelling, engaging, and very clear. Fewer than four stanzas of four lines each effectively uses. Rubric for literary analysis student will interpret and analyze a work of literary merit. Grading your students work will be easier with this rubric that has all the essential components such as. During the course of this unit, you will be expected to write one literary analysis essay focusing on one or more, depending on the option you choose of the short stories weve read in clas. Message achieves purpose of encouraging one to vote. We will be learning about several different kinds of poems throughout the next couple of weeks which will be incorporated into your scrapbook. Rubric for poetry explication 6insightful understanding of the poem evidentconflict explained fully specific textual evidence to support. Readwritethink materials may be reproduced for educational purposes.
All quotations or examples clearly demonstrate and support the claim of the paper. Your essay should present a clear analytical interpretation of one aspect of the text at hand. The economic, connotative language seduces me into thinking and feeling about the subject in a new way. Innovative research methods andor data analysis methods developed. Ap english literature scoring rubric, freeresponse question. A poetry rubric criteria never sometimes always the poem has a distinctive voice or point of view. Comments, reflections, analysis and connections are made on almost all entries throughout.
868 701 314 1610 1106 1018 983 882 773 558 450 343 421 1463 1426 952 181 462 1071 1048 724 1353 784 1241 255 308 1177 231 1613 495 1156 1466 22 828 529 281 684 305 847